Brain scans show that mindfulness meditation for pain is effective and not merely a placebo.

Pain is a complex experience influenced by more than just physical sensation, including factors like mindset and expectations. The placebo effect, where symptoms improve due to an inactive treatment, is a well-known example of how expectations can shape pain perception. Mindfulness meditation, which has been used for pain management for centuries, was long believed to work by triggering the placebo response. However, new research shows this is not the case.

A study published in Biological Psychiatry reveals that mindfulness meditation activates unique brain mechanisms to reduce pain, distinct from those of the placebo effect. Researchers at the University of California San Diego School of Medicine used advanced brain imaging to compare mindfulness meditation, a placebo cream, and sham mindfulness meditation in healthy participants.

The study found that mindfulness meditation significantly reduced both pain intensity and unpleasantness, while also decreasing brain activity related to pain and negative emotions. In contrast, the placebo cream only altered brain activity tied to the placebo response, without impacting the participants’ actual experience of pain.

“The mind is incredibly powerful, and we’re just beginning to understand how it can be utilized for pain management,” said Fadel Zeidan, PhD, professor of anesthesiology at UC San Diego. “By separating pain from the self and letting go of evaluative judgment, mindfulness meditation modifies pain perception without drugs or cost, and it can be practiced anywhere.”

The study included 115 healthy participants who were randomly assigned to one of four interventions: guided mindfulness meditation, sham mindfulness meditation (focused on deep breathing), placebo cream (believed to reduce pain), or listening to an audiobook as a control. Painful but harmless heat was applied to the participants’ legs, and brain scans were taken before and after the interventions.

Using multivariate pattern analysis (MVPA), a machine learning approach, researchers examined brain activity patterns related to pain, negative emotions, and placebo responses. They found that while placebo treatments reduced pain to some extent, mindfulness meditation was far more effective, reducing synchronization between brain areas involved in self-awareness, emotional regulation, and pain perception. These changes were not observed in the placebo or sham mindfulness groups.

“Contrary to the assumption that placebo effects overlap with active treatment mechanisms, our results suggest that, in the case of pain, the two brain responses are distinct,” said Zeidan. “This supports mindfulness meditation as a direct intervention for chronic pain, not just as a trigger for the placebo effect.”

In modern medicine, treatments are considered effective if they outperform placebos. This study shows that mindfulness meditation surpasses placebo and engages different neurobiological processes, suggesting its potential as a treatment for chronic pain. However, further research is needed to confirm these effects in people living with chronic pain.

The researchers aim to develop more effective interventions by understanding the brain mechanisms of mindfulness, hoping to offer new pain management strategies for various health conditions.

“Millions of people endure chronic pain daily, and they may have more tools to manage it than we previously thought,” Zeidan added. “We’re excited to explore how mindfulness can be harnessed in clinical settings.”

For more information about our clinic, medical professionals, and treatment options, please visit our main website.